Well tonight was no different than two weeks ago….a meeting fraught with electioneering and pontification…..candidates running in the election trying to get their names out there by raising hands and getting the rules of order waived….and some seeking re-election that are currently fortunate to sit in the “big chairs” that seemed to use it for campaigning and electioneering rather than just doing their job…..so, I’m going to save myself some keystrokes and I’m not going to elaborate on any of that for them. I offered them my blog as a free format for 5 weeks to get their platforms out. Some wisely took that gift and used it. Others didn’t. Their loss.
RECOGNITIONS
Heritage Plaque Presentation for 65-67 Richmond Street, the “Thomas Drug Store” – Richard and Colleen Peddie
Mayor DiCarlo read the history of 65-67 Richmond Street (now currently River Book Shop) and cited how Mr and Mrs Peddie had refurbished the building. He then awarded them with a Heritage Plaque for their building.
DELEGATIONS
Request to Hold a Baptism in the Kings Navy Yard Park – Tony Jaber
Mr Jaber addressed council next. He was requesting to use the gazebo in the Kings Navy Yard Park for a baptism ceremony for his son and daughter-in-law. It seems that he had also had the same request in 2018 and it was approved.
This was short and sweet. Deputy Mayor Meloche made the motion to approve the request. Councillor McArthur seconded it. And it carried. Quick and efficient! Mr Jaber even joked that everybody from council was invited, just to bring a gift! LOL!!! 🙂
Request to Hold the 3rd Annual Rick Meloche Memorial Bike Ride at the Libro Centre – Darcy Haggith
Mr Haggith addressed council next. He said that he had organized an Annual Bike Ride twice previously but was remiss this time in getting the paperwork submitted on time. He promised it wouldn’t happen again and offered to answer any questions.
So, there was an accompanying report to this delegation that was brought forward.
3rd Annual Rick Meloche Memorial Bike Ride
Councillor Prue made the motion to approve the event as presented in the report. Here’s the recommendation and the motion:
It is recommended that:
1. The report from the Director of Parks, Facilities, Recreation and Culture regarding the 3rd Annual Rick Meloche Memorial Bike Ride taking place on Saturday, October 1, 2022 BE RECEIVED; and,
2. That Council APPROVE the event and DIRECT Administration to work with organizers to ensure compliance with Town policies and procedures given the tight timelines as detailed in this report.
Councillor Courtney asked if anything could be done to streamline the process for this event for next time, rather than having them come before council each year. (I almost laughed out loud! The previous council – the 2014-2018 term – loved to micromanage events and actually made a motion that every single event had to come before council for approval, rather than go through an internal event approval committee. I sat through so many meetings where event organizers and volunteers would have come before council year after year after year…..and if anybody has forgotten who was on the previous council that thought this was a great idea….just look it up…..) CAO Critchley said that administration would like to put something in place for all of the recurring events and that only new events would have to come before council. (Ironically that is exactly how it was before the old council turned it into a micromanagement horse and pony show…..)
And the event was approved.
The New 256 Dalhousie Street – Richard and Colleen Peddie
This is VERY exciting news for Amherstburg!!!!! Mr Peddie spoke first and explained that he was before council seeking a demolition permit for 256 Dalhousie Street. He explained that he owns Black Dog Entertainment along with his wife Colleen. Mr Peddie explained their vision to increase the economic and social health of Amherstburg. He explained how they are now living their vision and admitted it was strange to be requesting a demolition permit since they are heritage minded and rebuilt the Book Shop as well as the Panetteria building. Mrs Peddie then spoke and explained that the building itself does not have any heritage attributes but that they will fund and install a plaque to recognize that in 1799 the lot was reserved for the occupation of John Sparkman, the Barrack Master of Fort Malden.
Mrs Peddie explained that the new building would house a restaurant as well as 12 boutique hotel suites and retail space on the main floor. She explained that in 1866, Amherstburg had 9 hotels. Today, in 2022 we have none. She noted that Leamington, a town of similar size has 9 hotels/motels available. Mrs Peddie then showed pictures of the new proposed boutique hotel and it was BEAUTIFUL!!!!!
A lengthy (and useless) debate about parking ensued. Councillor McArthur inquired about the timeline. Mr Peddie said that, if approved, the demolition would happen before Christmas and a cement base would be finished as quickly as possible. He explained that time is money and that they wanted to move ahead as quickly as possible. Mr Peddie explained that this was a multi-million dollar project. The parking debate came back and administration emphasized that there is no requirement for parking spaces and there is no bylaw governing parking spaces in the area. In other words, the developers are not obligated to provide parking.
Things were getting loud among the residents waiting in the gallery and it was at times difficult to hear what was going on. At one point, Mayor DiCarlo had to tell the people outside to keep it down.
Councillor Prue inquired about some legislation that was passed by the provincial government in July 2022. It seems that if everything lines up for a development, then site plan control is given to town administration, as per the new legislation. Councillor Prue then said that basically, all council can do is listen to and thank the delegates.
256 Dalhousie Street Demolition and Future Building – Colleen Fox and Don Parks, Salmoni Condominium Owners
Ms Fox spoke next. She mentioned her concern for the maintenance of the Salmoni Building. She acknowledged that they do not have control over the view that they enjoy from their building. She felt that the new hotel would have a negative impact on the lighting in their condominiums.
Mr Parks said that he had spoken to Anthony Leardi, our local Member of Provincial Parliament. Mr Parks said that council has the right to oppose this new building, as per his understanding from Mr Leardi. Mr Parks felt that the development was being pushed through and then also spoke about the parking concerns that he has. Mr Parks also felt that the Heritage Committee should not be recommending this building and that they had gone too far beyond their job.
Councillor Courtney asked for clarification that council was only deciding on the demolition and that council did not have a right to decide on the site plan with the new provincial legislation.
Ms Osborne, Director, said that as of July 1st, the provincial government redirected all site plan control to administration. She said that the height of the new building is allowed in the entire area downtown. She noted that the boutique hotel on Ramsey Street was all approved with no requirements for parking either. Ms Osborne noted that the Peddie’s are building a hotel that adheres to ALL of the rules.
Councillor Simone clarified that the Heritage Committee had followed regulation 906 and had to review anything in regards to properties of interest. She explained that the Committee had done what they were allowed to do and had not gone above and beyond their purview.
Ms Osborne, Director explained that there were 2 matters before the Heritage Committee. First, to evaluate the intent to demolish. Second, to approve the building design due to the location.
The debate raged on. Finally, Mayor DiCarlo noted that council had talked about everything except the demolition of the property, which was what to be voted on.
There was a motion made to receive the delegation. That carried.
Notice of Intent to Demolish-256 Dalhousie Street
So now they brought forward the report with the intent to demolish the building at 256 Dalhousie. Councillor McArthur said he had met with the residents of the Salmoni Building. He acknowledged that they are losing something. He noted though that the town at large will gain a hotel, a restaurant and some retail space. He noted that the potential development is for the good of everybody. It will bring people to Amherstburg. Councillor McArthur said he’d rather see people walk 3 minutes to a hotel than drive 30 minutes to a hotel in Windsor. (Bingo!!!!!! We’ve got to have places for people to stay overnight IN Amherstburg!) He felt that the hotel was for the greater good of Amherstburg and that a hotel has been the biggest ask from the community.
Councillor Prue felt that council had heard the residents’ concerns. He was shocked that the government had put through this legislation without any fanfare. He felt that Mr Leardi’s information was not correct and felt that the residents should ask Mr Leardi why he and his government took away their rights.
Councillor Courtney noted that council was approving a demolition and that the Peddie’s were in compliance. He also noted that the Salmoni building itself fell under the same bylaw as this new building does and that is why the Salmoni building is as tall as it is.
The debate raged on and on…..
Finally, the motion was on the floor :
It is recommended that:
1. The report from the Chief Building Official and Director of Development Services dated September 15, 2022 regarding Notice of Intent to Demolish-256 Dalhousie Street BE RECEIVED; and,
2. The application for demolition of 256 Dalhousie Street BE SUPPORTED
3. Remove 256 Dalhousie Street from the Properties of Interest list
It went to a recorded vote :
In favour : Unanimous
(My personal side note…..Amherstburg NEEDS hotels!!!! And yes, we need more than one!!!! There is another boutique hotel in the works on Ramsey Street, and I am hopeful we will see the hotel on the Amico property on Dalhousie Street……council should be welcoming these developments with open arms. Yes, I can see that the Salmoni residents are losing something. My neighbour could decide to tear their house down and replace it with a 3 story house. What could I do? Nothing. Such is life. Things change. There are no guarantees. And ultimately, this hotel is for the greater good of Amherstburg. And, long term, beautiful developments next door to a property, generally increase the value of the properties around them…..right?)
New Policy: Development Charges Interest Policy
There was a little bit of discussion about this, but honestly I couldn’t even hear it. People were leaving after the previous issue and it was too noisy. The motion was made for the recommendation :
It is recommended that:
1. The Development Charges Interest Policy BE APPROVED as recommended in the report from the Director of Corporate Services/CFO September 21, 2022.
And it passed.
Belle Vue Expression of Interest
After a few questions, Ms Osborne explained that an Expression of Interest allows council to receive ideas and possibilites for Belle Vue. It seems that it is open-ended and much less detailed or stringent than a Request for Proposal. Councillor McArthur wondered how they could ensure that the house would be protected and also protect the town’s interests. Ms Osborne said that the Expression of Interest proposals, the building is a priority.
Councillor McArthur wondered what it would cost just to get the house up to snuff. Ms Baillargeon, Director of Parks said it was hard to say with the rising price of building materials but that $15 to $20 Million plus would be a good estimate.
Finally, a motion was made for the recommendation :
It is recommended that:
1. Council RESCIND Resolution 20210614-209 to issue a Request for Proposal for the Belle Vue Property;
2. Administration BE DIRECTED to issue an Expression of Interest (EOI) to consider development proposals for the Belle Vue Property, inclusive of a requirement for all proposals to include provisions to restore and preserve the historical Belle Vue building, as an initial vetting of viable projects, and;
3. Administration REPORT BACK to Council on the various EOI proposals with recommendations on which proposal(s) should be invited to proceed with a Request for Proposal for the development of the Belle Vue Property.
Appointment of Election Compliance Audit Committee
Every election needs an election compliance audit committee. This committee can, if required, audit any candidates financial statements in regards to the election. There weren’t any questions and this recommendation was approved :
It is recommended that:
1. The Amherstburg Election Compliance Audit Committee (AECAC) BE ESTABLISHED for the 2022-2026 term of Council;
2. The Amherstburg Election Compliance Audit Committee Terms of Reference BE ADOPTED;
3. The following three (3) lay members BE APPOINTED to the Amherstburg Election Compliance Audit Committee for the 2022-2026 term of Council:
a. Paula Parker
b. Justin Rousseau
c. Robert Honor
4. By-law 2022-060 being a By-law to establish an Election Compliance Audit Committee for the Town of Amherstburg for the 2022-2026 term of Council be read three times and finally passed and the Mayor and Clerk BE AUTHORIZED to sign same.
2022 Second Quarter (Q2) Variance as at June 30th, 2022
This carried with no discussion.
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
Councillor Prue felt that since this term is almost over, he made a motion to forward the unfinished business list to the next council. Councillor Courtney seconded it. That carried. Good luck to the next council with this! LOL
And suddenly it was 7:22 PM and the meeting was adjourning!!!!!
I think this council only has two meetings left? I’ll have to check the calendar, but either way, the election is less than one month away now!!! Time flies when you’re having fun! LOL See you in a few weeks!